Q:
I’m thinking about registering for a writing class, but the price is a
little steep for my budget, and I’ve never even heard of this teacher.
Any recommendations?
A: First, high five to you for
wanting to improve your style, your voice, your understanding of the
craft by signing up for a class. And your “I’ve never even heard of
this teacher” comment tells me that, in addition to your willingness to
work at your craft, you’re also a smart shopper. That has never been
more important than in these tough economic times.
I’ve met far too many
struggling writers who’ve allowed uncredentialed instructors to lead
them astray with misinterpretations of information “borrowed” from the
pages of how-to-write books. “Those who can, do; those who can’t,
teach” might be true in other fields, but in publishing—an industry
that requires writers to stay at least one step ahead of the latest
trends—you can’t teach others to do what you aren’t doing yourself! To
be sure, these phony instructors cost students money, but they also
cost valuable time and, in some cases, the confidence to keep trying.
In my decades in this business,
I’ve learned a ton of stuff at The School of Hard Knocks, like “Never
take anything for granted” and “Spend your money wisely”—solid advice
for members of any profession, but particularly useful for writers. The
money we’re paid in exchange for countless hours of research,
interviews, writing, and rewriting too often adds up to less than half
the minimum wage . . . especially early in our careers. So forking over
a portion of hard-earned cash to enroll in a writing class is important
stuff, and we owe it to ourselves to make wise choices about the types
of classes—and instructors—we’re spending that money on. (If I had a
dollar for every student who told me how one of these faux instructor’s
half-baked lessons led them astray, why, I’d have a couple hundred
bucks. No kidding!)
Literally thousands of writing
classes, workshops, and seminars are listed online, in pamphlets
distributed by community colleges, and on 3x5 cards tacked to local
library bulletin boards. Some are affordable, others can empty bank
accounts. If, like any smart shopper, you’ve done your homework and
believe the lessons you’ll learn are worth the price, go for it.
But before you scribble your
name on a personal check or a Visa receipt, do yourself a financial and
professional favor: check out the teacher.
While it’s been my experience
that most writing instructors have the credentials to teach, I can list
far too many whose padded CVs match nothing more than their bloated
egos and do not qualify them to teach others to write.
You wouldn’t allow some dude on
a street corner who says, “I’m a pediatrician!” to examine your baby,
would you? Nor would you let some stranger who knocks on your door
claiming to be a roofing contractor put new shingles on your house
without making sure he’s licensed and hasn’t racked up a long list of
complaints with the BBB. So you owe it to yourself to find out:
• Can the
instructor back up claims that s/he is a “multi-published” and/or
“award-winning” author?
• Can the
instructor point you to real books—produced by legitimate
presses—on the shelves? If they’re able to name a title or two, look
for copyright information about the book(s); if a publisher isn’t
listed online, that’s a pretty good sign it’s a “vanity press” (the
route taken by desperate people who, after dozens of rejections, pay a
glorified printer to turn their manuscript into something akin to a
novel). It isn’t a pretty question, but you need to ask, “If these
‘authors’ aren’t being recognized by legitimate publishers willing to
invest in the work, do I really want them ‘teaching’ me?”
|
• Were the
instructor’s awards presented by real and existing
organizations and institutions, or are the kudos nothing more than
fiction, written to further pad the instructor’s opaque CV? I am
acquainted with a handful of these phony author-teacher types who not
only invented their awards, but the organizations that presented them
as well. So now you have to ask, “Is a person who’d manufacture
credentials someone I can trust to share valuable how-to-write
lessons?”
• Are claims of “teaching experience” bona fide, or still more fiction?
A phone call to the institution(s) where the instructor claims to be
affiliated will enlighten you; if no schools are listed, ask the
instructor for names of the school(s) where teaching experience was
supposedly acquired, then call the institution(s) and check things out
for yourself. Better to invest a few minutes up front than spend six or
eight weeks in a class where everything is bogus! (That handful of
wannabe teachers I mentioned? I know that, while their names were
listed in pamphlets and/or brochures, the courses never got off the
ground because nobody signed up for them.)
As
often as not, these so-called instructors manage to pull off a really
good con, and end up teaching a writing course or two. But anybody with
a computer and access to a copy machine can retype and/or photocopy
pages from “how to write” manuals and pass them off as classroom
handouts. So you have yet another question to ask: “Do I want these
thieves teaching me?”
Dedicated doctors whose patients
request second opinions happily connect patients with whatever
information might answer their questions, and qualified writing
instructors have no problem providing proof that they’ve earned their
claimed credentials. If they truly are who they say they are, the
information won’t only be readily available, but also they’ll lead you
to it! (Why wouldn’t they if they have nothing to hide?)
Just because you’ve chosen to
write Christian fiction doesn’t mean you deserve to get less for your
money, or that you should have to “make do” with less than qualified
writing instructors. You work hard for every dollar and have a right to
get your dollar’s worth.
“Let the buyer beware” has been
good advice for centuries . . . with good reason. And it’s my opinion
that God inspired the adage!
|